[Auntiesue]

Quote: Originally Posted by KoiCop I hear what you're saying about cold water stress, Sue, but here's the thing: It's only December. From what I've read, healthy fish in a healthy pond going into winter normally wouldn't be showing this level of stress this soon? That's why I think there's another dynamic going on here, perhaps one that's related to their condition prior to going into winter?

Oh I totally agree!! Everything should be looked at before deciding it's simply the cold. If I remember correctly (without going back and reading all the posts) there was a sudden cold snap. Even in the early months of winter, I've seen fish react to changes in water temps that have not been that cold. As often is said, these fish are individuals and each will respond differently. I suspect, but won't say for absolute surety, that this is cold water stress related. If anything else, the water will have to be warmed up anyway to treat any parasite issues, so why not get a head start on it now and bring the fish inside, warm her up and see what you find?