| Hi again JR,
Feel free to post the pics of DOC build up, and I'll explain again... None of these ponds have surface skimmers. The foam that you posted before was not DOC. This was foam built up on ponds that had only been running a few days with fresh water. The foam was solely the result of Lactic Acid Bacteria (OMX) being added to the ponds. This is done to each and every pond whenever a new 'batch' of Koi are added. The stuff is brown, and like treacle, and judging from the smell, is probably a form of molasses.
How many closed ponds have you seen without skimmers that don't suffer from foam? Also, bear in mind that the best way to create foam on any pond, is with a waterfall.
DOC seems to be something that you keep bringing up, and you also keep saying that the systems can't work on closed systems. Maybe they defy the rules of your filtration book, and I must be honest that I too (and the rest of the World) was scepticle of these systems. But, they seem to work well on every closed system they run on in the UK. They maintain good water, with no brown discolouration, KH levels that are kept up more easily, TDS levels that are kept down easily, and water parameters that all of their users didn't think possible. Take a look at the pics on my website. Ian Gaham's pond, and Colin Hughes pond don't even have surface skimmers, but where are the signs of DOC's? My small pond also has no skimmer, and yet no DOC's. I realise that you are arguing that they can't work, and with honest concerns of such. But, the evidence suggests that they defy theory, and simply give incredible results. Do yourself a favour and email me. I will in turn give you the phone number of EVERY person that runs these systems. You can then phone each of them and find out their thoughts, and results. When you have done this, come back and post up the feelings of these people. Better still, you and Bil should come over sometime, and I'll take you on a Bakki Showered pond tour, and you can take all the water tests you like.
As Bern said at the top of this page, Mr Richards ran it submerged and noticed big changes. He is one of many.
Sorry if it seems I am biting a little, but we have had these board discussions time and time again, and nothing really changes.
There is another scenario here, which I can appreciate... that is, the newcomers come here, and start the same thread on Showers (every few weeks/months), and hence you feel it your duty to post your same thoughts again, in order that the newcomers can see them, in case the missed the previous episode. This being the correct scenario?... I look forward to next time ;-)
Shiromuji... All rats aside, I am confident you will be surprised with the media, when you get it. Good luck.
Best regards,
Mike. |