Rank these Shiro 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th.

[aquitori]

Rank these Shiro 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th.

[Akinosan]

A_B_D_C or A_D_B_C can't make up my mind

[aquitori]

1st A
2nd D
3rd B
4th C

[Nancy M.]

by the photo's I will go with A,D,B,C..

[keokoi]

D A B C for me...

[Nancy M.]

Quote: Originally Posted by keokoi D A B C for me...

Joe, I have to agree with you, D is awsome, would like to see some
moto-sumi on right pec, then that would be my number 1 choice.

[keokoi]

I excused the motogoro and pic quality as A is of course a better pic and does not show any imperfections. My reasoning for picking D It was a toss up but I went with D also cause I like the head to shoulder..

Joe

[aquitori]

Well A is #1 choice, inazuma shiro is rare and the balance of pattern on a gosanke conformation is really ideal. D is #2 reason being is pattern is great too, but still can not beat the conformation of A, the simplicity and rarity of pattern on A is one that can not be matched. B is #3 reason being is that it has the body but striking appeal isn't as strong as C, but beats out C by conformation. C conformation is okay. The body line is a typical shiro body or old style bodyline. I would prefer gosanke body, but you cant ask anymore than what the fish is already. The pattern would rank this fish higher but the lack of pattern on the weak tail joint has bumped it down....

[jbolding]

I will go with A D B C, however it is kind of hard to judge due to the differences in pic quality.

[andy rose]

d,a,b,c for me