Rank these Sanke. Good, Better, Best

[Vogata]

Is C Tategoi? Are there newer pictures or information regarding these three available?

[aquitori]

Quote: Originally Posted by Vogata Is C Tategoi? Are there newer pictures or information regarding these three available?

These are all current pics....I think all the fish are tategoi.

[ockoi1]

B=Best ( I've seen it in person...much better when you look it closely)
A=Better ( male fish from majestic koi.com)
C=Good ( nice koi, good body conformation)

[aquitori]

Welcome to the board. ockoi1..

[RogerL]

C = good
A = better
B = best

[Super Kindai]

Quote: Originally Posted by aquitori Rank these Sanke. Good, Better, Best Which is your pick for tategoi(worthy to put back in the mudpond)

Are they 3 years old, about 26" - 28" ??

[68bruin]

C,A,B

C is best for me because body is best - commanding koi - pattern is the most interesting and balanced, sumi is best in placement and blackness, tail tube is thickest, hi looks dense. I don't think the pec fins are bad, just turned when pic taken. The head shape is best of three. Fish looks like has personality plus. Only negative for me is yellowness of head and fins (big neg) but I would love to have this fish.

A is second in conformation, also excellent, hi pattern is good but sumi certainly not balanced at this time. shiroji is best of three.

B is third in conformation, and has a scatter-gun, messy, unattractive sumi pattern placed on a good hi pattern except I'm not taken with the two small red spots behind the head. I think the pec fins are fine, again just turned when pic shot, but head shape not as good as other two in my opinion.

judging only from pics - not "in future, this or that will happen"

[aquitori]

Quote: Originally Posted by Super Kindai Are they 3 years old, about 26" - 28" ??

Yes they are in that age range and size range.

[PapaBear]

Has anyone else noticed that B is either rated as Best and Tategoi or Worst??? Sentiment seems to run pretty equally both ways.

[ockoi1]

I would like to ask aquitori which one you will you rank best, better, and good in order?