Mikey . . .
Missed seeing you at the Seminar. What happened?
Like you, I was there last Feb when this sanke was unboxed straight from Japan. I remember looking at Sakuma-san's photos of his many, many koi, with his handwritten ratings (A, AA, AAA) of each one. As I remember, this was the only tosai in his shipment that
he labled 'tategoi' -- and I do seem to remember you calling for it?
Imagine my surprise when we saw it swimming in one of the back tanks last Saturday! Ken said it was female, which Nakayama-san later confirmed.
So, a beautiful female sanke with a maruten 4-step pattern, tsubo sumi on the shoulder (and in all the shiro breaks straight back to the tail), excellent shiro, even hi, and acceptable conformation for her age and size: What's not to love?
If the pepper sumi (Matsunoske line) consolidates, and the somewhat yellowed head lightens, she should be stunning when she finishes.
And this time, I didn't pass on her.