Motoaka . . .

[KoiCop]

On a kohaku, who agrees (or disagrees) that:

1. motoaka is a sign of very high quality hi?
2. motoaka should grow out as the koi gets older?

How about on a showa?

(Bonus points for experience. )

[aquitori]

1. motoaka is a sign of very high quality hi?

This question is yes and no. Hobbyist shouldn't rely on this one sign of quality they should also focus on the depth of hi on the rest of the body. I have seen Kohaks with red pecs and have seen there beni just go down hill.

2. motoaka should grow out as the koi gets older?

If the fish is of high quality the red pec should pull in a bit closer to the base of the pec. If the red pec spreads(niban hi) as the fish grows it is a sign of poor quality.

[RayJordan]

I agree with toni