Do you use Potassium Permanganate?

[moikoi]

have PP on hand but afraid to use it.

[B.Scott]

Quote: Originally Posted by MikeM I know of no reason to use PP other than treatment of confirmed infection by trichodina. ...none. Dangerous stuff that, at best, disrupts the natural biofilm/algal communities that define a 'mature' pond. Justifying use on the basis that no harm was observed, or that a mature biofilm can endure if done 'properly', is simply closing one's eyes to the known reality. It is rather like an alcoholic observing that his liver has not ceased to function... yet.

I agree with you Mike... to a degree. PP is a tool and nothing more. It can be used when needed to treat a degree of problems but shouldn't be used nilly-willy.

What it is not is a tonic, additive or way of correcting a poorly designed pond. If one needs KMnO4 to keep your pond clean, the ORP high or the water clear, you should address the problem at it's source and stop looking for a band-aid. Get a better filter, larger pond, better water, less fish and do more frequent water changes.

That or find a new hobby.

B.Scott

[Russell Peters]

Quote: Originally Posted by B.Scott I agree with you Mike... to a degree. PP is a tool and nothing more. It can be used when needed to treat a degree of problems but shouldn't be used nilly-willy. What it is not is a tonic, additive or way of correcting a poorly designed pond. If one needs KMnO4 to keep your pond clean, the ORP high or the water clear, you should address the problem at it's source and stop looking for a band-aid. Get a better filter, larger pond, better water, less fish and do more frequent water changes. That or find a new hobby. B.Scott

Well said.

[RookieKoiGuy]

Quote:
Originally Posted by B.Scott
I agree with you Mike... to a degree. PP is a tool and nothing more. It can be used when needed to treat a degree of problems but shouldn't be used nilly-willy.

What it is not is a tonic, additive or way of correcting a poorly designed pond. If one needs KMnO4 to keep your pond clean, the ORP high or the water clear, you should address the problem at it's source and stop looking for a band-aid. Get a better filter, larger pond, better water, less fish and do more frequent water changes.

That or find a new hobby.

B.Scott

Well said.



Now we have seen the bad and the ugly about PP.....
Anything positive about it lol

Always need both sides!!
Tom

[KoiCop]

Quote: Originally Posted by RookieKoiGuy Now we have seen the bad and the ugly about PP..... Anything positive about it

PP can be used in water temps where the use of Proform-C would be precluded.

PP (measured with a gram scale, used in ponds with known/accurate volume and monitored with an ORP meter) is safe and effective for the eradication of parasites like costia, chilo and trich.