Online koi photo contest COMMENTS

[cppond]

Okay, so in discussing the koi in the contest we are not to give details about the koi or provide additional pictures to enhance the discussion.

Fair enough. Your house, your rules.

[Nancy M.]

Quote: Originally Posted by cppond Okay, so in discussing the koi in the contest we are not to give details about the koi or provide additional pictures to enhance the discussion. Fair enough. Your house, your rules.

I see no problem with details such as, size, breeder, age..

[Campcheryl]

I see no problems either with fish background but I would have perferred it to wait until after the fish were judged. I was enjoying looking at the fish and reading comments but now it seems to be a whole other ballgame. Let's get back to just our comments...no more pictures... and after the judging then the floor can be opened to discuss all aspects of the fish. JMHO

[Nancy M.]

Thank you Jim for cleaning up this thread... Now lets get back to the comments on all these beauties..

[jnorth]

Quote: Originally Posted by dcny Jim, Not to create more work for you and everyone else but could we ask the participant to include breeder, age and size info on all the fish and have that posted as well? I think it would help as part of the learning exercise. Thanks, Dan

It doesn't matter to me really as that info will not be passed on to the judge. All he is getting is printed photos. Please start a new thread though if you want to discuss in-depth one koi or do comparisons.

[jnorth]

Quote: Originally Posted by cppond Okay, so in discussing the koi in the contest we are not to give details about the koi or provide additional pictures to enhance the discussion. Fair enough. Your house, your rules.

You can if you want but again please do so in a seperate thread to discuss a single koi or do comparisons. Also the photos entered are photos entered. I will not be adding or switching out photos once I've posted them.

[Meg]

did you get mine Jim?

[jnorth]

Quote: Originally Posted by Meg did you get mine Jim?

Was it a hi utsuri? I replied to one email that was sent to me with no username. Maybe thats you?

[Meg]

yup that was me, thought I signed that e-mail, sorry

but look closer
it is a showa

[jnorth]

Quote: Originally Posted by Meg yup that was me, thought I signed that e-mail, sorry but look closer it is a showa

Lol sorry I only looked at the thumbnails. Haven't viewed it full screen yet.