No announcement yet.

PP dipping or Salt dipping?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • PP dipping or Salt dipping?

    As it looks now a days salt dipping seems to only prevent certain things..PP dipping seems to do alot more..I wondered what hobbyist thought about PP dipping over Salt dipping and vice versa.
    The world sleeps as the chance to learn something new passes.
  • #2

    I'm not in favor of PP dipping. Salt dipping to remove slime coat between moving a fish from one healthy pond to another is fine by me. Salt dipping an already stressed koi (from shipping or otherwise) doesn't seem that wise -- better to have a good Q-tank ready. Salt dipping in place of a proper Q is right out. Salt dipping then putting the fish back into a infected and untreated pond -- useless.


    • #3

      Idea behind dipping is flawed. Parasites may drop away to escape the active ingredient in the dip, and some may be killed immediately, but the only way to kill/remove all the parasites in a brief dip is to expose the koi to high concentrations involving excessive risk. A dip is useless for viral or bacterial infections, which are my primary concerns.


      • #4

        Gotta agree with Mike. PP can do a lot of damage. I know some dealers that use it sucessfully in a routine they do with new koi to rid them of parasites. But you'd better Know what your doing! I think any Dr that deals with living things needs to adapt the same mentality to " do no harm".
        Dick Benbow


        All content and images copyright of: